ClickUp vs Asana for Consultancies: Which Runs a Billable Business Better?

For most consultancies, ClickUp tends to win over Asana because consultancy work is rarely just "tasks in a project" — it's discovery calls, proposals, billable time, client-specific deliverables and retainer tracking, and ClickUp's flexibility handles that mix natively where Asana needs more workarounds. Asana remains a strong, simpler choice for a consultancy running straightforward project checklists with no need for time tracking or complex client structures built into the same system.

I'm Jack Lenton, a ClickUp Verified Consultant at Toki, a Norwich-based automation consultancy — and a consultancy myself, so this comparison is written from inside the exact problem it's answering.

How is a consultancy's workflow different from an agency's?

An agency usually runs multiple people through a shared production pipeline — campaigns, sprints, creative rounds. A consultancy is more often a smaller team (sometimes one person) running several client relationships in parallel, each with its own discovery-to-delivery arc, billable hours to track, and a proposal or scope document that needs to map cleanly onto the work actually done. The tooling needs overlap, but a consultancy leans harder on time tracking, client-specific views, and keeping scope visible against what's billed.

Where does ClickUp win for consultancies?

Native time tracking against tasks, custom fields for tracking scope and billable status per client, and the ability to build a genuinely different structure for each client relationship without fighting the tool. ClickUp's flexibility, which can be overkill for a simple creative pipeline, is exactly what a consultancy juggling several distinct client engagements needs.

Where does Asana win for consultancies?

If your consultancy runs a genuinely simple, repeatable process — same deliverables, same stages, every client — Asana's cleaner, more opinionated interface can be faster to set up and easier for a small team to adopt without configuration. It's the better choice if you specifically don't want the flexibility ClickUp offers, because that flexibility is unused overhead for you.

What about time tracking and billing?

This is usually where the decision gets made in practice. ClickUp has native time tracking built into tasks, which can feed billing directly. Asana's time tracking is thinner and more often handled through a third-party integration, which is an extra moving part for a consultancy that bills by the hour.

How Toki sets up ClickUp for consultancies

The same shape as any build: a discovery conversation about how client work actually moves through the business, a proposed structure to review first, the build walked through on Loom, live training, and a plain-English handover document.

Frequently asked questions

Is ClickUp better than Asana for a consultancy?
Generally yes, particularly where billable time tracking, varied client structures, or custom reporting matter. Asana can still be the right choice for a consultancy running a genuinely simple, repeatable process.

Does ClickUp have native time tracking?
Yes, time tracking is built directly into tasks, which is useful for consultancies billing by the hour without needing a separate time-tracking tool.

Is ClickUp harder to set up than Asana?
Generally, yes — ClickUp's flexibility means more initial configuration. That trade-off is usually worth it for a consultancy managing varied client engagements, less so for a simple, repeatable process.

Almost done! When you're ready, here are four ways I can help you:

1. Read it. A guide on how to use ClickUp and actually make it work for you.
2. Connect it. Let's be LinkedIn pals. I make funny videos sometimes.
3. Workshop it. Book a 30-minute chat to talk processes and build a Miro together.
4. Go for it. Fill in my contact form — let's talk ClickUp or Automations. Whatever tickles your pickle.

Wanna hear from the unfiltered version of me? Sign up to my newsletter. The Working Notes. 2 minute reads. Behind the scenes. Hopefully helpful. Maybe funny.